Personality assessments are more popular in hiring than ever, with over three-quarters of employers using personality and skills tests as a standard part of their vetting processes. A flood of AI-polished resumes has made it harder to evaluate candidates on paper, and more organizations are turning to assessments to get beyond the surface.
That instinct is right. But the formats gaining the most traction right now carry a design flaw that undermines the very thing they’re supposed to measure — and most hiring teams don’t realize they’re collecting noisier data because of it.
The issue comes down to how personality assessments are structured. Many of the most widely adopted tools on the market today use a forced-choice format, which requires candidates to compare a set of statements and identify which one is most like them and which is least. However, when candidates are spending several minutes parsing subtle semantic differences between options, they’re often problem-solving instead of self-reporting. To be clear, this is a question about personality measurement specifically. Cognitive ability tests work differently — they have right and wrong answers, so comparing options is the point.
Assessment design is a science decision, but it’s also a people decision. The
Read Complete Article